I decided it was time to dive deep, compare these two classics, and share my honest thoughts on what each flavor brings to the table. So if you're debating which custard monster flavor to try next, stick with me — this one's for you.
Why Custard Monster Deserves the Hype
Before I pit Vanilla against Butterscotch, I have to give props where they're due. Custard Monster has built a reputation for delivering rich, velvety flavors that don’t just mimic desserts — they are desserts. These aren’t your typical artificial-tasting blends; every bottle I’ve tried has tasted like it came straight from a bakery.
With a range that includes hits like custard monster blueberry, Strawberry, and the two contenders in this showdown, it's no wonder they're a fan favorite among vapers who love a sweet, creamy experience.
Meet the Contenders: Vanilla vs Butterscotch
Let’s talk flavor profiles and what makes each one unique. Both are rooted in custard, but they each bring their own twist to the creamy classic.
Vanilla Custard
Vanilla Custard is what I’d call a comfort vape. It's warm, smooth, and subtly sweet, like a homemade custard dessert straight out of the oven.
What I loved:
Balanced sweetness – Not overpowering, but still indulgent.
Smooth finish – It doesn’t hit too hard, making it an all-day vape.
Nostalgic vibes – Reminded me of vanilla pudding from my childhood.
Flavor Notes:
Creamy vanilla bean
Soft eggy custard undertone
Light caramelized sugar on the exhale
Honestly, this one is a crowd-pleaser. It’s simple, elegant, and incredibly satisfying when you want something mellow and consistent.
Butterscotch Custard
Now let’s talk about Butterscotch — the bolder sibling. This flavor is rich, decadent, and a little more indulgent than the vanilla version.
What stood out:
Deep caramel notes – There’s a toasty, buttery flavor that hits just right.
More complex – Layers of custard, butterscotch, and sugar all intertwine beautifully.
Great throat hit – A bit stronger than Vanilla, but still super smooth.
Flavor Notes:
Melted brown sugar and butter
Dense, creamy custard base
Slight hint of toasted vanilla
If Vanilla is like sipping a milkshake, Butterscotch is like diving into a warm, gooey caramel dessert. It's bold and flavorful without being too much.
Vaping Experience: Which One Wins?
When comparing these two custard monster flavors, I found myself appreciating both for different reasons. Here’s how they stacked up across a few key categories.
Flavor Intensity
Vanilla: Mellow and smooth. Subtle sweetness that doesn’t overwhelm.
Butterscotch: Rich and bold. If you’re into stronger dessert flavors, this one delivers more punch.
Winner: Butterscotch — purely for the depth of flavor.
All-Day Vape Potential
Vanilla: Absolutely an all-day vape. Gentle enough for long sessions without flavor fatigue.
Butterscotch: While amazing, it can be a bit rich for constant use.
Winner: Vanilla — it’s easier to stick with over time.
Uniqueness
Vanilla: Classic and safe, but not groundbreaking.
Butterscotch: More unique, with a deeper flavor profile that stands out.
Winner: Butterscotch — for stepping outside the box.
Pairing with Other Flavors
One of my favorite things about custard monster flavors is how well they mix or pair with other e-liquids. And trust me, experimenting with blends is half the fun.
Vanilla pairs beautifully with:
Fruit flavors – Especially custard monster blueberry, which adds a juicy kick.
Cinnamon or spice blends – For a warm, cozy combo.
Coffee or mocha flavors – A perfect breakfast vibe.
Butterscotch is best with:
Tobacco blends – Adds a sweet edge to a robust vape.
Nutty flavors – Think hazelnut or almond for a dessert-like twist.
Banana or caramel – If you want to really indulge.
What About Nicotine and Smoothness?
Both Vanilla and Butterscotch are available in nicotine salt versions, which I personally love for a smoother throat hit and quicker satisfaction. Whether you prefer a 3mg freebase or a higher salt nic option, both flavors handle the nicotine really well without feeling harsh.
I noticed that the Vanilla felt just a bit smoother on the inhale, while Butterscotch had a more noticeable throat presence — which some folks might prefer depending on their style.
Where to Find Them
If you’re searching for either of these, chances are you’ll find them by looking up custard monster blueberry, Vanilla, or Butterscotch at your favorite online vape shops. Local shops might carry them too, depending on your area. It’s always worth checking for new arrivals or combo deals — these juices go quick once people find out about them.
Final Verdict: Which Should You Try?
So which one should you go for?
If you’re new to dessert e-liquids or want something smooth, sweet, and easy to love, Vanilla Custard is your best bet. It’s versatile, reliable, and seriously satisfying.
But if you’re ready for something richer, more indulgent, and packed with caramelized depth, Butterscotch Custard might just steal your heart (and your taste buds).
My Suggestion:
Try both! Honestly, I keep both on rotation depending on my mood. Vanilla is my weekday chill flavor, and Butterscotch is my weekend treat.
Whether you're already a fan of custard monster, or you're just now exploring the lineup, you really can’t go wrong with either of these. The brand continues to impress with not just classic custard flavors, but creative blends like custard monster blueberry that keep me coming back for more.
Which side are you on in this flavor showdown? Let me know — I’d love to hear what your taste buds think!
